In an interview with ABC 11, Edwards, a dentist, explained he wrote in the notes section of the form that “we were a groom and groom.” He added: “It’s not like we can ignore that and then show up.” The couple didn’t even get to show up because within two days, the estate replied by saying the venue has “chosen not to participate in same-sex weddings at this time.” The reply also included suggestions for alternative venue sites.
In a statement to ABC 11, the owners said the venue has “always welcomed” guests and workers of “all orientations” and does not discriminate against people or a group. And what about the couple turned down for a wedding spot, you might wonder? When the news outlet asked owners about the specific couple, they responded by characterizing their response to the couple as “respectful” and “kind.”
They went on to say to the outlet: “When magazines and others chose not to do business with us because of this position, we respected that decision. That is their right. We do not judge them or retaliate because they chose to not respect our religious beliefs. The argument can just as easily be the same for us as we’re being made to feel like the other. We are not the ones attacking, slandering and threatening others for their beliefs.”
Mind you, being gay (or anything under the LGBTQ+ umbrella) is not a belief. It is not a choice.
During an interview with the outlet, Henderson, an attorney, shared a similar perspective, noting that “we did not choose to be gay.” He continued: “The fact that we don’t have access to things other people do is discrimination in my eyes. I think everyone has the right to believe what they want to believe to an extent. I don’t think you get to be racist because your religion tells you to be racist. I don’t think you get to be homophobic because your religion tells you to be homophobic.”
So, how is this legal? North Carolina does not have a statute protecting against discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. So, as a private business, the venue can technically refuse to host same-sex weddings. As reported by local outlet WRAL, the spokesperson North Carolina’s attorney general confirmed this to the news station when a reporter inquired after hearing about the couple’s story.
And North Carolina isn’t an oddity in this, either. For example, as Daily Kos covered in early April, a tax preparer in Kentucky hung a sign in their window clarifying that they don’t “recognize” same-sex marriage. Legal? Technically, yes.
What can we do? Push for an Equality Act for federal protections. And remember that “red” and “purple” states are not places to simply shrug off. There are queer people (as well as other marginalized groups) in all of these places, even in those with the most anti-LGBTQ policies, and every single person deserves fair and equal representation and protections.